Detroit City is the Place to Be
The Afterlife of an American Metropolis

By Mark Binelli
2013, Metropolitan Books, 320 pages,
$28 hardcover, $12 E-reader version
4 ½ out of 5 stars
Reviewed by Chris Wendel
This is a book that might not fit the category of a typical business book. “Detroit City is the Place to Be” is as much about urban history and social behavior as it is about business development.
Detroit is a city that took plunge before the rest of America earlier this decade and fell further into the abyss more than any other city. Several books have recently made the rounds relating to Detroit’s scary new normal. My two choices were Mark Binelli’s “Detroit City is the Place to Be” and “Detroit, An American Autopsy” by Charlie LeDuff. After receiving strong recommendations on both, I opted Binelli’s book because of my familiarity with his previous work.
For years a popular adage was: “If Detroit sneezes, the rest of Michigan catches a cold.” While the city of Detroit proper no longer has a huge base of manufacturing jobs, it remains a major part of Michigan’s persona. Today, we are obviously influenced with state resources that are directed towards Detroit and the prevailing fact that Detroit remains the core of Michigan’s major metropolitan area.
Author Mark Binelli takes a long view of Detroit, going back to its original settlement by the French explorer Cadillac and following a reoccurring of pattern of violence and upheaval from the 1700’s through to Detroit’s pinnacle as the seat of America’s Industrial Revolution. Instead on playing the blame game on the massive failure of Detroit’s economy, Binelli illustrates well the stark contrast between what existed 40-50 years ago and what is left to deal with today.
Binelli begins with a reality check. A city of two million in 1967, Detroit was once the nation’s 5th largest city. It now has just over 700,000 residents and ranks 18th. Roughly 40 square miles of Detroit are now vacant land. For some perspective, all of San Francisco is 47 square miles. According to Binelli, in 2008 Detroit had 90,000 fires and the highest murder rate in the country.
Binelli’s narrative of Detroit’s early history through 1967 serves as a fitting backdrop to where Detroit has now landed, illustrating ongoing rifts between races and socio-economic groups, and the ongoing friction between Detroit itself and is outlying suburbs.
Without getting caught up in the blame game, “Detroit City is the Place to Be” spends the majority of its focus on present day Detroit, on who and what remains. Binelli immersed himself for many months in an area of downtown Detroit close to where his immigrant parents ran a knife sharpening business in the 1940-60’s. Growing up in St. Clair Shores outside of the city, Binelli had spent a good portion of his adolescence near the family’s Detroit business. His return in 2010 provides a startling first person account of the city’s pockets of new development and outlying empty urban prairie.
Binelli who is a gifted writer, novelist, and contributing editor with “Rolling Stone”, interviews dozens of Detroit’s current players including former mayor Kwame Kilpatrick, Detroit police chief Ralph Godbee, urban gardeners, tour guides of derelict buildings, movie film crews, neighborhood watch leaders, students at a school for pregnant teenagers, officials from the UAW local, longtime residents that stay, and even transplants to Detroit who move there from unlikely places such as Hawaii and Europe.
There are plenty of unique stories within the story here including a murder trial where Binelli is the only journalist showing enough interest to attend (because there are so many such trials within the city every day), and citizens protecting themselves and their homes with arsenals of guns and weapons. The result is a fascinating book that reveals the stark realities of today’s Detroit but also offers some glimmer of hope for a city that if we’re fortunate, will become a positive inspiration for Michigan’s future.